By 
I wish I had a nickle for every email, post, message or tweet I get about some company, agency or sponsor not following their own contest rules. Sadly it’s so common, I’d be rich. What is worse, those same companies sometimes disqualify entrants without merit. Both of these actions have the potential to light a powder keg of social media backlash.
Do you follow your own rules?
Let’s begin with one of my biggest pet peeves. Companies not following their own rules.
Some of the most common rules broken by sponsors are:
- not conducting the drawing when stated in the rules.
- not announcing the winners, anywhere.
- if it’s a judged contest, choosing a winner that doesn’t meet all the selection criteria.
The social backlash happens when entrants start asking:
- has the drawing been conducted?
- who won?
- why did that entry win when it clearly didn’t follow the rules?
Why should this type of social questioning bother you?
- Firstly, entrants shouldn’t have to be creating these types of posts if the sponsor or agency is doing their job. That said, all companies are run by fallible humans, but it’s the response to those queries that will determine the size of the backlash.
- Secondly, it’s a direct reflection on the sponsor’s business. The thinking is, ‘If the sponsor can’t run a simple contest, then how well can they run their company? Can I trust their product or service?’
Did you vet the potential winners?
Many companies don’t follow their own rules by also awarding prizes to entrants that should have been disqualified. This always leads to a wide-spread social media backlash, usually bigger than the original promotion, all with the wrong type of PR.
The blame can’t all be laid down at the feet of the sponsors.
With the anonymity of online profiles and the easy of creation comes rampant cheating. It’s easy for anyone to set up several Facebook, Twitter and Instagram accounts increasing their odds of winning a prize.
For those computer savvy, even contest apps that claim they prevent cheaters are vulnerable to being hacked and entries stacked. In October of 2015, Journal de Montreal uncovered a cheating ring involving more than 10 people, all connected to the mastermind.
There is no perfect system to catch all cheaters, but starting with social searches for similar profiles, and online searches for IP addresses, will weed out some of the culprits. If the Journal de Montreal can do it, so can you.
What can you do to ensure you are not awarding a prize to the wrong person?
Vet the contest database. Search the entries for duplicates, and any other criteria not following the official rules, then delete them. You would be amazed at the number of sponsors and agencies that do not take this simple step.
Do not rely on the drawing feature of sweepstakes apps as stated above, they can be hacked. Always export the database, search for duplicates and then conduct the drawing.
Depending on promotion, you may wish to hire a detective that specialists in sweepstakes delve deeper. Would you want to find out the person you awarded a big prize to on national television is a criminal?
Are they really cheating?
When money is involved jealousy can rear it’s ugly head. Don’t always take the word of a fellow entrants sending you messages, posts, tweets, etc. crying fowl about a specific entrant cheating. Listen and then conduct your own investigation.
The social outcry usually happens during voting contests. It’s why I recommend companies never host them.
Yes, there are people with large social media reaches, but votes can easily be bought. Google ‘buy votes’ and you get over 144,000,000 results. The votes suppliers are getting more and more sophisticated, allowing votes to be submitted by different IP addresses at different times so the votes look authentic.
I have also seen my fair share of petty online squabbles, mainly on Facebook, when jealousy reigns supreme, dragging the sponsor into a drama that shouldn’t have happened in the first place.
What can you do to ensure a smoothly run social contest?
- Always have official rules. There is no excuse, even on Twitter. You can link to a rules page.
- Ensure the marketing team reads and follows those rules. If the entrants have to, so should you.
- Conduct a fully vetted drawing. A thing well done is worth doing.
- Publicly announce the winners. This quells the fear that ‘no one ever really wins, do they?’
- Listen to your customers, prospects and entrants. They may have a valid point, or they might be whining, but you can’t assume either until you do your own research.
- Be as authentic and transparent as possible online. People love to connect people and brands they like. Put yourself in their shoes. Who do you engage with via social media?
What do you do to avoid social media backlash?
Latest posts by Carolyn Wilman (see all)
- Are Promotional Game Sweepstakes Rigged? - August 15, 2018
- 6 Elements of Running a Successful Instagram Contest - April 30, 2018
- Has Facebook Killed Social Media Sweepstakes? - March 15, 2018
Many times the breakdown is at the marketing level or agency level. The onus is on the brand to be responsible for its agents. For more on legal issues with vote farming and cheating, see my post: http://maximizesocialbusiness.com/vote-farming-and-cheating-in-social-media-contests-9633/
I won a contest on IG back in March and never received my win…I have emailed and messaged him on several occasions and still nothing!!!